Tuesday, 17 April 2012

Keeping sourcing local.....the Zara way

One of the biggest challenges in SCMluxe is to keep production or "make" local to retain quality and brand value (refer post country of origin). In the fashion industry lead time is crucial...hemlines can change by the time it takes for a shipment to arrive from China. Hence to avoid overstocking (besides brand considerations)companies try to keep sourcing local but this has a huge impact on costs. Inditex (Zara's holding company) sources almost all its stocks from the local region in Spain, Portugal and Morocco. This means Zara's costs (and prices) are higher compared with competitors like H&M, Gap etc which source from China. But it also means that Zara follows a pull rather than push model of stocking. Instead of depending on forecasts (notoriously unreliable in the fashion industry) to decide on stocks, Zara actually analyses the actual orders or material flying off the shelves and adjusts its inbound stocks accordingly. This means lead times have to be very short to manage stock outs at stores - which again is possible through local sourcing. Competitors on the other hand need to predict demand (fickle at the very least in fashion) and place orders with suppliers in China to make up for the long lead times. Prices are naturally lower than at Zara but customers needing the latest fashion seem to prefer paying these prices rather than buying something that they don't want at that point of time (or not in fashion at the moment). Does Zara also benefit from lower costs due to overstocking to compensate for higher costs of sourcing?


 However going local is not all rosy....it throws up a very important limitation. What do brands do when they need to cater to emerging markets far away from the country of origin? Zara sees a huge potential in Chinese customers willing to spend on its clothes which is deemed as a luxury purchase...but are they willing to wait for it to be shipped across from Europe? Thus lead times and local sourcing can become an impediment to growth. Inditex is now focusing on scaling up its designers in Shanghai (currently 12 as compared to 250 in Europe). Thus the creative process of the supply chain is being moved closer to the market....but will this impact the brand value for the Chinese customer?....will they see Zara as a luxury product or simply another local company with mid level prices? We'll have to wait and watch...

Tuesday, 20 March 2012

Insourcing “Make” – British brands show the way

SCMluxe has always insisted that production or the “make” strategy is always retained in the country of origin (Refer posts location, SCM Make ) to ensure brand recognition, quality, lead times and most of all the mindshare of the customer as a luxury product. Let us look at 3 British luxury brands which have demonstrated this in differing ways:
Mulberry factory - Shepton Mallet, Somerset
1.       The Flag bearer
The British fashion house Mulberry has always explored and built upon le style anglais starting from tweeds and country jackets to its more contemporary bags and leather goods (the iconic Chiltern bag being an example). This remains so even after the takeover by Singapore based Ong Beng Seng from founder Roger Saul in a $12Mn buyout – in fact the new owners have not only retained its national heritage but expanded its appeal by bringing in contemporary British design.  They quickly realized that the leather goods and bags market was independent of culture and body type. For instance no matter if you were a size 0 or 10 or were from a culture that dressed conservatively, if you had the money, you could always show it off with an expensive handbag. So Mulberry invested heavily in the design and launch of its bags collection but also poured money ($8 million and counting) into its production facilities in Shepton Mallet, Somerset.  The factory now produces almost 30% of all Mulberry bags and employs more than 300 in the area. Each of the 300 will be specialized artisans skilled in cutting and processing leather. With over 140,000 bags being supplied to the world market from British shores, the brand retains its value and quality in the customers mind

2.       The Status Quo

Jaguar assembly plant - Castle Bromwich, Solihull

When India based Tata Motors took over an ailing Jaguar from Ford in 2008, the easiest way to cut costs and bring the company back to black would be to shift or outsource production to Tata’s expansive factories in India. However assembly of a Jaguar continues to remain in Castle Bromwich, England. Instead the company focused on bringing in new processes, improving efficiencies in sourcing and assembly as well as broadening the Landrover’s appeal in the market. Retaining the Landrover’s British heritage paid off this year with the division registering a profit of $1.7 billion after years of being in the red or barely breaking even

Burberry HQ - Horseferry Square, London
3.       The Prodigal returns
The success of Burberry’s iconic check pattern spurred the company into luxe status and as a symbol of British design and quality. However the pressures of being a public limited company and quarterly forecasts the company started selling licenses to manufacturers across Asia to produce and sell the plaid pattern on perfumes to purses to underwear. A resulting drop in quality, excessive volumes flooding the market and lack of control of display and distribution meant the brand lost its luxe appeal in the mind of the customers. It was now a mass market brand (very much like Pierre Cardin today) with large volumes, low prices and low margins. A price war meant customers were not willing to pay a premium for the product but expected it to compete with price and quality with other generic products. Shareholders finally saw sense in 2006 when the company started buying back the licenses under the stewardship of CEO, Angela Ahrendts. The cost of these buybacks were high but the company has managed to stay afloat by retaining its British tag – it now needs to build and restore customer confidence in its luxe status….all over again
Emphasizing national heritage helps established Western brands to retain existing markets and grow in the emerging markets of Asia and the Middle East. However what will their response be when Asian customers mature and demand their own heritage brands – will this be a competition to existing Western brands or will they simply open up an altogether new market?

Monday, 5 March 2012

Website Management for luxe companies: e-commerce or e-inform?

The internet is an increasingly important sales channel for most mass mechandizing products and one that traditional SCM has incorprated as a unique distribution channel with very low set up costs. SCMluxe however treats the internet as more of an channel to inform a customer of the product rather than to actually sell. This is mainly due to the nature of distribution in luxe products that requires a high customer touchpoint and experience before the purchase is made. Thus SCMluxe will normally utilize the internet to inform and build brand awarenedd for potential customers. Hence one needs to keep in mind several very imporatnt facets when designing and maintaining an internet presence for a luxury good:
  • Utilize own websites to promote and inform about the product or associate with an internet site that suitably identifies with the brand. "Never" utilize mass e-retailing sites like e-bay, amazon etc (as seen from the recent slew of court cases between Tiffany and e-bay...)
  • Ensure the website informs rather than "sells". This also means go slow on the animations/ special effects etc which might not really show up on devices like iPads or iPhones. Alternately have dual versions for mobile devices. Remember customers will prefer to intensively research and compare a high value product before heading down to a store for the actual purchase
  • Meta tag appropriately so that the web site shows up for the correct search criteria and is ranked fairly high up. Use SEO or Search Engine Optimization techniques. Remember that using excessive flash diminishes chances of search engines recognizing and ranking web sites higher up in priority/relevance
  • Use membership based access to special views on the website
Any other pointers readers can suggest for websites?

Half minute to download and heavy on flash

Saturday, 18 February 2012

Meeting modern SCMluxe challenges - a lesson from Azimut-Benetti

Many European luxury goods companies have faced bankruptcy in the current recession and recently have been acquired by business houses that are neither in the luxury trade nor from the same geographical and cultural sphere. An example is the recent acquisition of the Italian yacht maker Ferretti by the Shandong Heavy Industry Group, a Chinese enterprise with very little exposure to the luxury trade. Though Ferretti was saved from bankruptcy, it lost its “Made in Italy” tag and all the brand value this implies in the customer’s mind. How can luxury goods companies retain its cultural heritage (location and artisan workmanship included) and yet retain its cost effectiveness and cater to markets that demand industrial mass production mindsets in terms of quality. A successful example of a company which achieved these seemingly contrasting goals is of another Italian luxury boat maker Azimut-Benetti which continues to be family owned and debt free while maintaining their market share and profitability through the years. Let us look at some of the strategies that Azimut has put in place and see if lessons can be drawn from them:
1.       Constant Innovation
Azimut has recognized that a totally manual approach to production will not survive long term if the brand had to retain its “Made in Italy” tag without offshoring  to cheaper locations of manufacturing with low labour costs like China rather than the expensive Italian labour market. Hence the company has developed innovations that help address the high cost of Italian labour (or European for that matter). For example painting a yacht which takes thousands of man hours of effort is today done by robots (a first for any yacht maker). Also innovations in the product design itself such as lighter hulls (created by a process of vacuum infusion) resulting in less pollution and greater strength enable differentiation of the product vis a vis competition. Lastly a corporate mandate to increase fuel efficiency of every new model by 10% ensures that Azimut-Benetti remains leagues ahead of cheaper alternatives from low cost countries or competition (which uses cheaper mass production techniques)
2.       Building an entrepreneurial organization structure
Azimut is organized into 3 segments with each segment manager effectively running his unit as an entrepreneur. This level of delegation of authority and responsibility ensures that it’s not purely the “creative” minds at the top who manage the organization in its entirety. Managers can then build boats and manage their business profitably rather than rely on the “creatives” or the professional technical design team who may not be geared up for this role. Thus independent manufacture and marketing of boats is possible without the assistance of the core design team (normally a part of the family behind the business). Thus a level of professionalism is created within a family owned business
3.       Focus on Quality at activity level
Azimut has divided the entire process of boat making into 25 different activities with each activity headed by a process owner who signs off on the quality of the output for that activity. Thus as the construction passes through each activity or process, a series of quality checks are done, and the process owner for that activity signs off on the quality sheet before it passes onto the next sequential activity. Hence by the time the boat emerges at the end of the 25th activity one has a perfect product. An example of a quality test in one of the activities is immersing the boat in a swimming pool for 48 hours post which it is immersed in its natural environment, the sea. A battery of tests carried out at these stages before the activity owner signs the quality sheet for this activity

Azimut 62S Italia - "Made in Italy"
Lastly an important lesson from Azimutt-Benetti for luxury companies is to go easy on debt – all expansion and investments have come from internal accruals and Azimutt even today is a zero debt company. Ferretti on the other hand was heavily leveraged ....... until Shandong Heavy Industry Group came along to help manage its debt repayment schedules and avoid bankruptcy

Sunday, 5 February 2012

SCMluxe for premium products - a lesson from Apple

I bought an iPhone...yes, not a "smartphone" but an iPhone. So what makes this difference between Apple products and its competitors? The difference is in the strategies of SCMluxe that Apple uses more in parts than in its entirety. Does this make Apple product luxe or even premium? - not really (the Vertu could be one), but it does show that some of SCMluxe strategies could work very well for non-luxe products.

Lets see what Apple does and does not do, that makes it so successful vis a vis other competitors:

SCMluxe Strategies:
  1. Distribution is controlled and in-house with almost no external contractors/wholesalers or even retail points. Notice the long queues outside Apple iStores every time a new product is released....the deliberately restricted volumes of first sale, hype before release and carefully constructed point of sale experience
  2. The iStore experience - unlike its competitors the point of sale for Apple is an extension of the brand and its carefully managed to convey their messaging across all the stores especially in the iconic stores in London's Covent Garden or New York's Fifth Avenue. The retailing is very much done in high streets with expensive decor and location just like all luxury goods stores
  3. Product quality - is another factor that Apple scores over its competitors. The design and quality makes no allowance for mediocrity (or the customer, for that matter). And like all self respecting luxury goods companies makes no allowance for the convenience of the customer (the BMW experience in leg space in earlier posts) - note the requirement for Apple customers having to lug the product to an iStore every time one has to replace its batteries instead of being able to do it at home. No other competitor actually would dare inconvenience its customer this way
  4. Design - is the soul of Apple and is kept not only in-house (and in the country of origin, USA) but kept fiercely guarded with heavy investments/budgets
  5. Pricing - though the price of its products are only nominally higher than its competitors, Apple strictly follows the no-discount or sale policy of SCMluxe
Non SCMluxe strategies:
  1. Production/Manufacture - is almost completely out of its country of origin with a supply chain spreading across global low cost locations (mainly China)
  2. Traditional mass production conveyor belt production systems - almost no artisanship or manual craftsmanship involved or communicated
  3. Broad based customer segment not exactly targeting the high end luxury customer
Surprisingly this unique mixed up strategy works for Apple remarkably well and there are lessons to be learnt from it - the most important one being that SCMluxe components work for non-luxury products too. Only one must carefully analyse and see where and what components will work for the premium/mass premium product that one is considering the supply chain strategy

Thursday, 26 January 2012

Disposal of obsolete or dead Stock and SCMluxe

Obsolete stock or dead stock is the bane of all supply chains and traditional industries have evolved innovative ways of dealing with this. In this article we’ll discuss what is to be done with existing obsolete stock and not on ways to reduce it.
Obsolete stock?
Obsolete stock is managed in traditional supply chains by:
1.       Disposing off vide discount sales
2.       Refurbishment (seen especially in home electronics industries)
3.       Stripping and recycling parts of the product to recover as much value as possible
4.       Lastly responsible disposal (landfill, incinerators etc)
In SCMluxe these options don’t really work:
1.       Discounts or Sales: No discount or sales offered in the luxe industry since this will affect the brand and the more loyal customers
2.       Refurbishment: This would mean that the quality of the product was not of the highest level earlier, again a violation of a luxe product’s positioning
3.       Stripping for parts and recycling: Gives raise to fears of counterfeiting and brand logo/recognition appearing on non-luxe products
The only option left to most luxe houses is then to dispose off obsolete stock in landfills or incinerators. Another method is to donate obsolete stock to a carefully controlled but worthwhile cause which might result in some publicity as well as disposal of stock. Are there any other ways or strategies that luxury houses use to dispose dead stock? Do let me know….

Thursday, 19 January 2012

Centralization as a key to visibility and profits

The key feature of the retail industry and luxury goods in particular is the large variation and seasonality of sales. This seasonality is compounded by the high number of SKUs and the turn over in these SKUs by season and geography. Fashion apparel is a stark example of this with last seasons’ fashion quickly becoming obsolete or dead stock. Similarly product variations by geography (smaller clothes sizes in Japan vis a vis Western markets) pose a problem in fulfilment as well as losses from excess inventory or stock outs.
This variation and seasonality leads to the well known bull whip effect wherein standard demand with only small variations in demand at the retail or point of sale grows into large variations as demand moves upstream into the supply chain (distributors, wholesalers, aggregators etc).  This ultimately results in supply chain inefficiencies of excess stocks/ stock outs growing as we move more and more upstream.
The Dunhill experience in centralisation
A selection of  SKU variations for a single product
Dunhill had a similar problem wherein small variations in demand at retailers magnified as the demand moved upstream. With over 30% of sales coming in from its wholesalers, the variation of demand at wholesalers was far more than that at the retailers end.  Some of the problems experienced by Dunhill other than stocking and storage was the complete lack of visibility of inventory across all stocking locations. With sales spread across 120 retail stores worldwide, this posed a huge logistical problem in fulfilling demand in an efficient (both in cost and lead times) manner. A strategy adopted by Dunhill to address this was “Centralization”. This included:
·         Centralisation of distribution – One distribution centre in Paris to service the US and European market and one distribution centre in Hong Kong to cater to the APAC market
·         Centralisation of merchandise planning and inventory management operations
This has resulted in increased profitability (“up 5% since implementation of centralisation initiatives launched” as per Rachel Brain, Merchandise Director), reduced inventory levels, lower dead stock and improved supply chain agility.