![]() |
| Luxottica HQ in Italy |
Strategies and thought on supply chain management for the luxury goods industry have been relatively under-developed and scarce. Through this blog, I endeavor to marry my expertise in supply chain management with my enduring passion for the luxury goods industry to develop content and discussions around enabling the industry with specialized supply chain strategies – SCMluxe
Showing posts with label location country of origin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label location country of origin. Show all posts
Sunday, 7 July 2013
Luxottica...an eye for vertical integration
Tuesday, 20 March 2012
Insourcing “Make” – British brands show the way
SCMluxe has always insisted that production or the “make” strategy is always retained in the country of origin (Refer posts location, SCM Make ) to ensure brand recognition, quality, lead times and most of all the mindshare of the customer as a luxury product. Let us look at 3 British luxury brands which have demonstrated this in differing ways:
![]() |
| Mulberry factory - Shepton Mallet, Somerset |
1. The Flag bearer
The British fashion house Mulberry has always explored and built upon le style anglais starting from tweeds and country jackets to its more contemporary bags and leather goods (the iconic Chiltern bag being an example). This remains so even after the takeover by Singapore based Ong Beng Seng from founder Roger Saul in a $12Mn buyout – in fact the new owners have not only retained its national heritage but expanded its appeal by bringing in contemporary British design. They quickly realized that the leather goods and bags market was independent of culture and body type. For instance no matter if you were a size 0 or 10 or were from a culture that dressed conservatively, if you had the money, you could always show it off with an expensive handbag. So Mulberry invested heavily in the design and launch of its bags collection but also poured money ($8 million and counting) into its production facilities in Shepton Mallet, Somerset. The factory now produces almost 30% of all Mulberry bags and employs more than 300 in the area. Each of the 300 will be specialized artisans skilled in cutting and processing leather. With over 140,000 bags being supplied to the world market from British shores, the brand retains its value and quality in the customers mind
2. The Status Quo
![]() |
| Jaguar assembly plant - Castle Bromwich, Solihull |
When India based Tata Motors took over an ailing Jaguar from Ford in 2008, the easiest way to cut costs and bring the company back to black would be to shift or outsource production to Tata’s expansive factories in India. However assembly of a Jaguar continues to remain in Castle Bromwich, England. Instead the company focused on bringing in new processes, improving efficiencies in sourcing and assembly as well as broadening the Landrover’s appeal in the market. Retaining the Landrover’s British heritage paid off this year with the division registering a profit of $1.7 billion after years of being in the red or barely breaking even
![]() |
| Burberry HQ - Horseferry Square, London |
3. The Prodigal returns
The success of Burberry’s iconic check pattern spurred the company into luxe status and as a symbol of British design and quality. However the pressures of being a public limited company and quarterly forecasts the company started selling licenses to manufacturers across Asia to produce and sell the plaid pattern on perfumes to purses to underwear. A resulting drop in quality, excessive volumes flooding the market and lack of control of display and distribution meant the brand lost its luxe appeal in the mind of the customers. It was now a mass market brand (very much like Pierre Cardin today) with large volumes, low prices and low margins. A price war meant customers were not willing to pay a premium for the product but expected it to compete with price and quality with other generic products. Shareholders finally saw sense in 2006 when the company started buying back the licenses under the stewardship of CEO, Angela Ahrendts. The cost of these buybacks were high but the company has managed to stay afloat by retaining its British tag – it now needs to build and restore customer confidence in its luxe status….all over again
Emphasizing national heritage helps established Western brands to retain existing markets and grow in the emerging markets of Asia and the Middle East. However what will their response be when Asian customers mature and demand their own heritage brands – will this be a competition to existing Western brands or will they simply open up an altogether new market?
Thursday, 21 July 2011
Da Vinci – an example of the importance of “Country of Origin” for luxury products
I spoke of the country of origin being one of the critical success factors in location and csf posts. (location and critical success factors for SCM-luxe)
Now here comes a perfect example illustrating the importance of “location” – even in China!
The Chinese are quite blasé of counterfeit Louis Vuitton bags and Rolex watches available in almost all Chinese city corners (apparently there are well defined locations in each city which specialize in such goods – albeit done surreptitiously). So when it was revealed by the New York Times (see http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/19/business/global/chinese-upset-over-counterfeit-furniture.html) that the upscale furniture distribution company Da Vinci was actually selling “made in China” products as “made in Italy” the reaction of the market was surprisingly virulent. Customers revolted, stormed the press conference by the company and a web campaign started to “out” similar company’s passing of local produce as luxury products made in more exotic shores.
![]() |
| Da Vinci's CEO, Doris Phua, breaks down after being
heckled by customers during a press conference
to address allegations of misrepresenting country of origin
of its luxury products
|
This reaction is as much a sign of the maturing of the Chinese market as far as luxury products are concerned but also the more fundamental aspect of the importance of location for a luxury product irrespective of the geography or market where the product is ultimately sold.
On the other hand a common complaint by Da Vinci’s customers was that they bought fakes at the price of a genuine article. Does this mean, that customers were ok with fakes as long as it was not at the price of the real one? The customers felt cheated? A case of limited morality or limited information sharing?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




